Tampilkan postingan dengan label USIH Blog. Tampilkan semua postingan
Tampilkan postingan dengan label USIH Blog. Tampilkan semua postingan

Jumat, 02 November 2012

An Interview with David Hollinger


David Hollinger, the S-USIH 2012 Conference keynote speaker, is the Preston Hotchkis Professor at the University of California, Berkeley.  He will be retiring from teaching following the 2012-2013 academic year.  Professor Hollinger kindly consented to be interviewed by me via email for our conference newsletter.  I have reprinted his interview below.

Alas, as our readers know, this year's conference was canceled due to the catastrophic effects of Hurricane Sandy. However, a .pdf of the conference newsletter will be available for download at the S-USIH website.  In the meantime, you can view and download the entire newsletter through my public Dropbox folder using this link. The 8-page newsletter features a piece by David Sehat highlighting and exploring the themes of the conference he planned so thoughtfully and well, an article by S-USIH President Paul Murphy discussing the possibilities of starting a print journal, a note from Allison Perlman about our plans for next year's conference, news and notes from our members, and other key information. It would have been my great pleasure and a real privilege to help distribute this newsletter in person at our conference. Next time.

___________

An Interview with David Hollinger
by L.D. Burnett

Q: The theme of this year's S-USIH conference, "Communities of Discourse," acknowledges and celebrates the enormous influence and usefulness of your conception of the field of intellectual history, a conception that is arguably "paradigmatic" in the Kuhnian sense of the word.  As you argued in the paper you delivered at the Wingspread conference, the notion of a "community of discourse" is a capacious one, able to accommodate a far broader range of subjects and subject matter than might be suggested by narrow definitions of what the term "intellectual" in "intellectual history" stands for.  In thinking about how this paradigm has functioned to frame the field of inquiry over the past four decades, do you find it still capacious enough as a way of conceptualizing intellectual history?  Are there ways of understanding intellectual history that this paradigm is strained to accommodate? 


A: I would not want to claim too much for the notion of “communities of discourse,” and prefer to see it mostly as a heuristic, not as a charter for the field. It is a heuristic in that it can help some good projects find themselves, but good projects are certainly not limited to those that operate within its scope. I am very glad that the notion continues to help colleagues design and defend their projects, but I pushed the notion more for reasons of the politics of the profession than for strictly methodological reasons. Of course the two are connected, but my big concern was to get the profession to acknowledge that the features of human life studied by intellectual historians left material tracings every bit as real as the material tracings left by elections, wars, social movements, demographic transformations, economic booms and busts, and other features of human life that historians took for granted.

This simple point was worth making because of the incessant chatter, even by people who should have known better, about the “relation of ideas to reality,” or “the relation of the interior of the mind to external life,” as if intellectual history was a series of speculations rather than an interpretation of documentary evidence comparable to that scrutinized by historians of other subfields. The vivid positivity, the concrete substantiality of our major subject matter—discourse as carried out by socially embedded human beings who left evidence of their doings in the form of letters, essays, diaries, books, etc.-- needed to be affirmed. Second, I wanted to remind colleagues of the value of the kind of history that focused on the questions thinkers are trying to answer and on how various individual thinkers answered one another’s questions and thereby participated in a community of sorts. This, too, seemed obvious to anyone like me who was raised professionally on Collingwood, but some social historians at the time seemed not to know that this was what most intellectual historians did. Indeed, I wrote the essay in a kind of fury in the fall of 1977 when I read the Wingspread draft of Larry Veysey’s paper, which I thought misrepresented the methodological issues in the study of intellectual history, repeated the worst of contemporary social history’s libels against intellectual history, and threatened to undermine the credibility of a professional practice that I believed to be sound. I had told John Higham, who organized the Wingspread conference, that I would write about Kuhn’s influence on intellectual history, but when I saw what Larry had written in his pre-conference draft (I had yet to send mine in) I scraped my own draft, and while still drawing some inspiration from Kuhn, wrote in a hurry a very different paper.

But the notion of communities of discourse proved of value to many scholars long after Veysey’s formulations were forgotten, and I suppose it was just as well that I dealt with Larry indirectly, never mentioning his name, because that better enabled the essay I wrote to have a life even after the proximate cause  for its composition had largely disappeared. I spent most of the essay citing examples of existing scholarship, to guard against the idea that I was inventing anything new: I was trying to provide a set of terms that I thought might have efficacy in the politics of the profession to describe and defend a well-established practice. Delighted as I am to see this set of terms still functional, I am pleased with this chance to underscore that I was not trying to “define” intellectual history, but only to vindicate a primary form of its practice.

Q: Your recent "state of the field" essay in the MIH forum touched on the connection between pedagogy and scholarly inquiry.  In what ways has pedagogy at both the graduate and undergraduate level shaped your own scholarly inquiry?  Do you see the possibility for "new directions in intellectual history" arising out of the discourse community of the classroom?

A: In my own case, there has often been a connection between my undergraduate lecture course and my scholarly writings. Several of my articles, most fully “Ethnic Diversity, Cosmopolitanism, and the Emergence of the American Liberal Intelligentsia” (1975) and “How Wide the Circle of the We” (1993) began as undergraduate lectures. I’d have a sense that this or that topic was important to the field that the course was supposed to cover, but the monographic literature seemed not right on point. Lacking a literature to harvest for my lectures, I would work up what seemed to me a sensible and sound take on the topic based on my own reading of what I took to be the most relevant sources. Then if it seemed that what I’d worked up for the students might even contribute to the scholarly conversation, I’d sharpen the lecture to the point that I could deliver it as a paper at the OAH (as I did for “Ethnic Diversity”) or the AHA (as I did for “Circle of the We”), and then, depending on the reception it got from colleagues, publish it. Undergraduate teaching has the splendid effect of forcing one to address large questions, and if the scholarly literature does not go after those large questions you have to do it yourself, and doing so can, in turn, blow back into the professional literature. Graduate teaching is something that I have enjoyed equally, but in my own case it has not had remotely as direct an effect on what I write as a scholar. Graduate students I see as fully part of the community of professional scholars, but undergraduates function more as a surrogate for the educated public at large and therefore they provide a different type of stimuli. 

Q: The Society for U.S. Intellectual History and the annual conference have their beginnings in the discourse community -- or one of the discourse communities -- of the blogosphere.  Because this medium of communication/interaction is technologically new, it is tempting to see the community constituted through it as also somehow new or fundamentally different from previous communities of intellectual inquirers.  But in what ways might the S-USIH exemplify continuity with a broader and older tradition of intellectual/academic communities?  What aspects of that longer tradition do you hope the S-USIH will carry forward?

A: I am not sure that blogs create “new or fundamentally different” kinds of learned communities (perhaps they do, in ways that I do not discern?), but they surely help bring into the conversation of a specialized field a number of individuals who might otherwise not be as fully part of it as they should be. I am probably not a good person to explore this question, however, because I am lucky enough to be based on a campus where I cannot walk down the hallway from my office without running into someone with whom I can have an informed and animated conversation about the latest book or article. If I were not at one of these big campuses, with large faculties and a steady stream of bright, energetic graduate students passing through, I suppose blogs would mean more to me. Blogs enable a lot of folks who would otherwise not be in regular and direct communication to be in touch with each other whenever they feel like it, and surely that is a good thing. I’m also in the habit of treating print journals and books as somehow prior to blogs, as if blogs were something to go to once you’d finished (which I seem never to manage) reading all the other stuff. I don’t defend this attitude, but I do confess to it. I’m for blogs, just not very active in them.

Q: You published your first scholarly paper in 1968 and have announced your retirement from teaching in 2013; what changes in the field over that span of four-and-a-half decades are most striking to you?

A: In 1968 American intellectual history was very close to American Studies, and the ASA’s journal, American Quarterly, was a favorite place for intellectual historians to publish. That remained true through Bruce Kuklick’s editorship in the 1970s, but by the end of the 1980s that journal had narrowed its focus methodologically and chronologically. By the 1990s it was almost entirely a “cultural studies” journal focused on the period since World War II, and largely since the 1960s. I had published in AQ three times, had read it eagerly, and had even won one of the ASA’s prizes, but I have long since quit the ASA (as have most historians I know who used to be in it). The decline (at least from my point of view) of ASA and AQ has helped make space for the creation in 2004 of Modern Intellectual History and the simultaneous rejuvenation of  The Journal of the History of Ideas, both of which turn out to be much better for us than AQ for several reasons, one of which is that they comfortably integrate American intellectual history into the intellectual history of the North Atlantic West instead of tying it, as ASA and AQ did, to more narrowly Americo-centric concerns. So, while I long lamented the transformation of the ASA and AQ, I finally came around to realizing that the liberation of American intellectual history from American Studies was a blessing in disguise. The youngest cohort of US intellectual historians is much more likely than my generation to be fluent in German and/or French, and more and more of these younger scholars are engaged in trans-Atlantic projects. This cohort, moreover, is reclaiming the study of philosophy, theology, social theory, and social science that the American Studies movement at its best had engaged, too, but then largely dropped.

The closer ties between US intellectual history and European intellectual history encourage attention to aspects of American intellectual history to which the projects that have flown under the flag of “cultural history” have been less attentive. Cultural history has done a lot of great things for us, and deserves to be celebrated, but the anti-elitist strain within cultural history limited its scope. At the risk of appearing to ignore some other really good recent stuff, I want to mention the three 2012 imprints devoted to my main field of the 20th century to have hit my desk the most recently: Angus Burgin’s The Great Persuasion: Reinventing Free Markets Since the Depression, Joel Isaac’s Working Knowledge: Making the Human Sciences from Parsons to Kuhn, and Andrew Jewett’s Science, Democracy and the American University: From the Civil War to the Cold War. These three ambitious, rigorously argued, sophisticated monographs illustrate how, looking now only at the last couple of months of twentieth century studies, the cohort to which I refer is making the field of American intellectual history more vibrant than ever. 

Minggu, 23 September 2012

An Overheard Conversation: Loving History, a Sixteenth Birthday, Blogging, and Youth against the Youth Culture

By Elisabeth Lasch-Quinn

Yesterday, I suddenly found myself in the position of a fly on the wall in a conversation
between a graduate student in her late twenties and someone who was just about to
turn sixteen--today. It made me think of a different side of the subject of my recent posts
here regarding the drastically increased role of electronics technologies in early twentyfirst-
century life. While I've been voicing my concerns, of necessity, given my focus on
the fate of letter writing, in the more somber registers, I want to sound a different note
here. It's a rather simple one, and hardly new. I just want to add my own hope and
enthusiasm to that of others who see true benefit in some uses of the new medium.
Technology's role is all in how we use it and today some people are using it to
undermine illegitimate hierarchies and unfair limits on aspiration that are placed by the
dominant culture. While there are other examples, I'm thinking of the truly remarkable
blogs--the USIH blog is at the forefront of my mind, of course--that have arisen, outside
of the usual corridors of cultural power and influence. Some of these represent a true
alternative to prevailing practices and, because an alternative is so badly needed, in our
profession as in many others, I want to acknowledge this most emphatically. For all of
the drawbacks, there are heartening developments. One of them is the way in which the
art of blogging can allow people to move forward to fruition of their creative powers even
when the powers that be may never grant them permission or entrance to the club. As
the autodidacts inside and outside of professions prove again and again, industry and
true passion for a subject can constitute their own invitation to the table.

First, the conversation; then just a hint of one of the many reasons why some of the
more penetrating blogs out there today can be so inspiring to someone probably
basically a Luddite at heart (my preference will always be for the real, no matter how
you spin it).

The near sixteen-year-old began by expressing her passion for the liberal arts,
especially history. While to date she had done well at the full range of subjects taught in
school, and cultivated an interest in all aspects of the curriculum, which worked well in
accordance with her aims of doing well, she admitted to being less than excited about
what was on offer in her eleventh-grade science and math classes. She revealed this in
a set of questions revolving around a two-pronged issue for her: what difference there
might be, if any, between the pursuit of science and math, which she saw as lying on
one part of the spectrum, and another part involving history and literature, where she
confessed her greatest interests lay; and whether it was acceptable, at her level, to feel
a strong preference for the history, in particular, over science. Of vital importance in
understanding her tentativeness, perhaps, and the rather turgid response her inquiry
drew, in turn, was that her interlocutor declared herself to be pursuing a doctorate in
chemistry.
The graduate student began with a dubious claim, which maybe you have heard before,
or even hold to be the case. The 15-year old had not heard it before, and, in fact, I too
had been previously spared. It is the idea that the liberal arts has to do with people
whereas science concerns "the world." (The latter words even seemed to be uttered
with a kind of breathlessness that seemed to underscore the limited horizons of the
former, but I could have been hearing things.)

Well, this dichotomy did not sit well with the teenager and I must say, more power to her.
With the utmost respect and even deference, she begged to differ, mostly by means of a
quiet yet persistent line of inquiry. She got across her sense that history, her favorite
subject, also has to do with the world, just as science can have rather a lot to do with
people; in fact, people and the world are so closely entwined as to be difficult to
extricate from one another. The graduate student, conceding nothing, pulled out all the
stops, including referring to the great many people she knew who thought as she did.
The teenager's argument, for it really was one, however cloaked in query, continued to
be conveyed in this deft manner until the topic changed somewhat, along with the tenor
of the conversation, into a question of whether it is really possible to know, at such an
early age, whether one's main interests lay in history and literature or the hard sciences.
The youngster momentarily sought the firmer grounding, usually a sure-fire argument
winner in this age of personal preference, the emotivism Alasdair MacIntyre criticizes,
by reiterating and underscoring the depth of her interest in matters of interpretation over
scientific empiricism, but this was a no go and she soon returned to her style of goodnatured
yet relentless questioning. It was a formidable modus operandi. Her stealth
would have put many a trained rhetorician to shame.

The 15-year-old unfurled a line of reasoning qua inquiry that ran something like this (I'm
paraphrasing for brevity's sake): if she herself already knew that this was where her
greatest passion lay, and that the subject was simply pregnant with potential illumination
and exciting beyond one's wildest imagination, wasn't it okay to go ahead and choose
now, before her own inner judge and jury, securing a verdict that it was fine to cultivate a
vision of a future for herself that involved the liberal arts somehow and did not
necessarily involve math and science? Was it normal and healthy to have this
inclination? It seems to me she was wondering, as teenagers are wont to do, though
often regarding matters less academic, whether her desires were natural and legitimate.
She seemed to be referring to the allowances we tend either to allow or deprive
ourselves regarding the hopes and dreams that populate our hours and days; in the
case of the young, as we desperately await the chance to grow up and enter into adult
work life as equal partners.

The graduate student's response interested and, I admit, surprised me by its certainty.
The years separating the conversation partners couldn't have been much more than
eight or ten. Yet they didn't seem close to seeing eye to eye on this, at least in that
sitting. For the older person, who had clearly now opted for role of advisor, insisted that
the advisee was way too young to cast her lot--that it was premature to bestow her
scholarly affections in this way. Look at me, she said. At your age I thought I would be a
nurse and "now I am a chemist." When asked by her companion whether being a nurse
wasn't also a profession, she was told it is "more of a trade."

There are all sorts of points latent in this rich (for someone in hearing range) exchange,
and you will take from it what you will. But the one that stands out for my purposes is
that here I saw a young person, poised right on the brink of the birthday we often think
of as a kind of landmark or turning point, the onset of adulthood, asking piercing
questions of herself and others about her present and future.

It was impressive.

What was she getting at, really, with this line of questioning? Did she really think she
needed someone else's permission to like some subjects and not others in high school?
Probably not. Did she want confirmation that it was okay not to like science? I doubt it,
as she seemed well aware the graduate student, given her own evident passion for her
own subject, would not provide anything of the sort. What were they arguing over and
why would neither budge?

Maybe it was just an obvious case of love of history coming head to head with love of
science. And the subtext might have been each subject's relative merits in representing
and illuminating "the world."

But also at stake seemed to be the meaning of childhood and adulthood and when and
where the one was to phase into the next. Unconsciously perhaps the fifteen-year-old
was thinking about what it meant to turn sixteen and the twenty-something
unconsciously reminding her that sixteen is not twenty something. We won't know the
inner workings of the unconscious and conscious minds of these incredibly bright and
thoughtful individuals.

It reminded me of the Cat Stevens song from 1970, "Father and Son," that non-duet duet in which the singer-songwriter sings both parts, expressing the tension in the intimate
generational bond, the father's primordial instinct to protect coming up against the son's
desire to be free--to get away from authority, yes, in the sixties' generation gap sort of
way but also to be free to enter full adulthood in that small "r" republican way we study
so much in our field. The song seems to be suggesting that the son wants to be freed
up so he can follow his own dreams in order to find out what unique contribution he can
make. The father counsels patience and conformity:

"It's not time to make a change,
Just relax, take it easy.
You're still young, that's your fault,
There's so much you have to know.
Find a girl, settle down,
If you want you can marry.
Look at me, I am old, but I'm happy.

I was once like you are now, and I know that it's not easy,
To be calm when you've found something going on.
But take your time, think a lot,
Why, think of everything you've got.
For you will still be here tomorrow, but your dreams may not."

It seems to me that the conversation to which I was privy had elements of this same
tension. The dominant culture we have inherited, charted in too-painful detail by recent
historians and social critics, is one that supposedly holds youth in high regard. Yet, as
we know well, by placing youth on a pedestal for people of all ages, as the most
desirable state, it fosters a basic defeatism or nihilism, since our nature, the fortunate
ones among us, is to grow and to age. If we cannot muster enthusiasm for those things,
the very definition of what it is to be alive, can we about anything?

One of the things that is so glorious about bløgging, as I've spelled it elsewhere in order
to distinguish the elegant, deep, worthwhile, and meaningful variety from the not-so, is
that it is, in some cases anyway, turning the mainstream cult of youth on its head, and
along with it some other cultish practices such as a kind of professionalism that
discourages free thought and speech until such time as a person has all of the proper
passports, visas, degrees, tenure and promotion votes--until all of the working papers
are in order. At the foundation of today's culture rests an unquestioned assumption--that
the longer we delay the onset of adulthood the better. This might be partially true
enough when we have an adult world of such dreary predictability as so much of ours
today, which is protected from any serious questioning by elephantine bureaucracies,
protracted credentialing systems, and narrow notions of professionalism that really
mean gatekeeping and homogenization. But it is sure to cut us off from the sustainable
practices and renewable intellectual energies we so badly need in order to marshal
forces against just such stultifying realities. Continually depleting the influx of the sorely
needed powers of new energy and fresh perspectives, all in the name of the protection
and extension of youth, has become a way of life. It never makes sense, but is
especially useless when there aren't even very many credentialized, overprofessionalized
jobs to speak of.

I think high-quality blogging is one of the more exciting things to appear on the
intellectual horizon in recent years. In the case of the contribution of newer scholars,
especially in a time in which the terrible outlook for the future of our field and the
humanities generally is a given, this public intellectual activity has potentially farreaching
ramifications for the prospects of our field and profession--and, to a certain
degree, the state of intellectual, social, and political life more broadly.

I think a lot about that line, the father's charge that you are young and it's your fault. Of
course, that charge is unfair; it goes without saying. How young we are is precisely one
of the only things for which we cannot possibly be held responsible. Then I remember
the wisdom and yearning of that remarkable conversationalist, who turns sixteen this
very day, and I am forced to ask...or can we?

She was quietly insistent on winning the case for at least a hypothetical acceptance that
her scholarly passions and goals might be real ones in the long-term, as if presciently
aware that if she does not press and even win the case now in behalf of her visions of
contribution and fulfillment she might be here tomorrow but her dreams may not. It was
as if she couldn't rest her case until the question was answered in the affirmative.

Happy Birthday, passionate young scholar, wherever you are. I have a feeling your
dreams will still be there with you, wherever you choose to go.

Jumat, 21 September 2012

S-USIH Publications Committee News


As our regular readers know, I was recently appointed by the S-USIH executive board to serve as the chair of the Publications Committee.  My colleague Tim Lacy is taking a temporary break from official S-USIH duties, and I am honored to serve out the remainder of his term.

There are a few items of news and business I would like to bring to the attention of our membership.

News

As stated in the S-USIH bylaws, the PubComm chair can appoint up to two additional members to assist in the work of the committee.  Thankfully, my colleague Ben Alpers has graciously agreed to continue his work on the Publications Committee.  As part of his PubComm duties, Ben is the editor of this blog.

I am also pleased to announce that Mary Ellen Lennon will be joining Ben and myself as a member of the Publications Committee.  Mary Ellen is an assistant professor of history at Marian University (Indianapolis); you can read her faculty profile here.  She will begin her stint with the committee after October 1.

I have also asked Mary Ellen to take over for me as our book review editor, and I'm glad to say that she has agreed to do so.  I'm pretty good at spinning plates, but doing triple duty on the Publications Committee is one plate too many.  So I'd rather hand one off than drop one.  However, I don't plan on laying everything on Mary Ellen's shoulders. We have a few book review roundtables coming up -- on Ray Haberski's God and War, on Kerwin Lee Klein's From History to Theory, and on Erik McDuffie's Sojourning for Freedom.  I will work with Mary Ellen on presenting the Haberski and Klein roundtables; our colleague Lauren Kientz Anderson has arranged the McDuffie roundtable, and she will be assisting Mary Ellen with that presentation.

In the meantime, publishers who wish to submit a book for review should contact Mary Ellen at this email address.

Business

As a regular feature in our S-USIH newsletter -- an edition of which will be published to coincide with this year's conference -- we plan to include a column highlighting professional news from our members.

If you have some news you would like to share with the S-USIH membership -- a recent publication, a new academic position, an upcoming lecture, a professional appointment to an editorial or governing board, and the like -- please let us know.

Send your news items to me, L.D. Burnett.  To be included in this fall's newsletter, news items from S-USIH members in good standing (join online here, or download this form and mail it in) should be received BEFORE October 5.

Besides member news, we would be glad to consider guest contributions from our members.  We are particularly interested in publishing reflections on the state of the discipline.  If you would like to submit a brief essay (1000 - 1250 words), please send that to me before October 5.

Additionally, this blog often features essays by guest contributors.  If you would like to write for the blog as a guest contributor, you can contact any of our regular bloggers with a proposal.  All of our bloggers have the opportunity to sponsor guest posts at their discretion.

Finally, we would be delighted to add some bloggers to our roster.  If you are interested in becoming a weekly contributor to the S-USIH blog, please contact Ben Alpers, our blog editor.

Thank you to our blog readership and to the Society membership for your engagement in our discussions and your support of our work.  If you have any suggestions or questions about the work of the Publications Committee, please email me, and I will be glad to discuss the matter with you.

L.D. Burnett
Publications Committee Chair

Senin, 06 Agustus 2012

A Creative Commons License for USIH Content

Like most bloggers, those of us who write and edit USIH are excited when people reproduce our work in other venues. But we were disturbed to discover recently that a blogger (who shall remain nameless) was republishing whole USIH posts under his own name.  Dealing with this unfortunate circumstance led to a discussion among the USIH bloggers about rights and licensing of USIH Blog content. After some discussion among the bloggers and the Society for U.S. Intellectual History's Publications Committee, which is responsible for this blog, we have come up with the following policy:

Starting on Tuesday, August 7, 2012, all text published on this blog -- both in posts and comments -- will be covered under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike license (CC BY-NC-SA 3.0).

Here's what the license does (I'm borrowing here from the plain-language version of the license at the above link):

This license allows anyone to freely copy, distribute, transmit, and adapt any posts or comments that appear on this blog, under the following conditions:

1) They must attribute the posts and/or comments that they copy, distribute, transmit, or adapt both to this blog and to the author(s) of the particular posts and/or comments.

2) They may not use posts or comments for commercial purposes.

3) If they alter, transform, or build upon posts and/or comments, they may distribute the resulting work only under the same or a similar license to this one.

Any of the above conditions can be waived if you get permission from the copyright holder, which is the Society for U.S. Intellectual History (see below). Where the work or any of its elements is in the public domain under applicable law, that status is in no way affected by the license. In no way are any of the following rights affected by the license: fair dealing or fair use rights, or other applicable copyright exceptions and limitations; the author's moral rights; rights other persons may have either in the work itself or in how the work is used, such as publicity or privacy rights. For any reuse or distribution, you must make clear to others the license terms of the work. The best way to do this is with a link to the plain language version of the CC BY-NC-SA license.

More important details of this policy below the fold....




Unless specifically noted, this license does not apply to images or video reproduced on this blog.

In order to make this policy work, and to provide the Society for U.S. Intellectual History (S-USIH) with some control over the content of this blog, unless otherwise noted, S-USIH will be the legal rights holder for all text published on this blog.  Your decision to publish a post or a comment on this blog constitutes an implied consent to grant S-USIH copyright over your post or comment and to publish it under the CC BY-NC-SA license.  As the rights holder, S-USIH will retain the right to waive any of the conditions of the license specified above.

Under the CC BY-NC-SA license, authors (like everyone else) will be largely free to reproduce what they write on this site. In addition, it will be the policy of S-USIH to grant authors of particular posts or comments a waiver of one or more of the conditions of the CC BY-NC-SA license other than the attribution requirement (e.g. to republish the comment or post as part of a commercial work or a work not covered by a similar license) unless doing so would somehow materially harm S-USIH (I don't anticipate that this will ever be an issue, but, e.g., our tax-exempt status could, potentially, be raised by certain waiver requests).  Authors of posts or comments seeking such a waiver should e-mail requests to the S-USIH Publications Chair. In addition, S-USIH will not grant waivers to anyone other than the author of a post or comment without the express written permission of the author of the post or the comment. Obviously, these policies regarding waivers cannot be extended to authors of anonymous comments.

Although simply publishing material on this website may well imply a transfer of rights without any declaration on our part, we feel uncomfortable applying this policy retroactively, which is why this policy will take effect at 12:01 am CDT on Tuesday, August 7, 2012.  A widget announcing the copyright status of posts and comments as well the CC BY-NC-SA license will appear in the right margin.

For general information about intellectual property rights and blogs, please see this page from the Electronic Frontier Foundation.

Rabu, 11 Juli 2012

What the Hell

A few weeks ago, this blog published Jim Livingston's savage critique of Paul Murphy's new book.  The critique was part of a roundtable organized by Tim Lacy, our outgoing book review editor.  I am our current book review editor.  When I read Livingston's piece, I thought, What the hell have I gotten myself into?

I wasn't just wondering about the book review editing gig, or doubting the wisdom of the blogging gig (from which I was taking a working break).  What I really had in mind was the entire field and practice of U.S. intellectual history. 

That review scared me to death.  It was a hit job; I mean, it was a frickin' crime scene.  I was stunned, shocked into silence -- sure that I had witnessed something awful and wrong, but afraid to say a thing about it publicly.  I did write Jim Livingston privately about it, but I didn't say a thing on this blog. 

Nobody did.  The whole day that review just sat there, drawing traffic like crazy, and generating who knows what back-channel conversations -- but eliciting not a single remark from any of us, all day long.  Then at three in the morning on the day after the essay went up, a blog commenter I hadn't seen in this space before remarked (in a way) on our collective spectatorial silence, but said nothing about the spectacle itself:  a senior historian practically eviscerating a junior scholar.

Finally, the day after the review went up, Dan Wickberg took Livingston on.  I saw Wickberg's name in the sidebar, and I thought, "Thank God; we're off the hook.  The Cavalry has arrived."  If anybody exemplifies both intellectual rigor and professional comity, it is Dan Wickberg. If anybody were to speak with unquestionable authority and unwavering collegiality, I knew that Dan would be the one to do it.

Then I came to the closing lines of his comment:

"Instead of farting in the museum, give us a careful and considered argument. We're all adults here; I think we can handle it."

I could not believe my eyes.  Farting in the museum?  Dan Wickberg wrote this?

What the hell!


But of course, when I re-read the whole comment, it made perfect sense, and I could see exactly what Wickberg was trying to do.  He was basically asserting that Livingston's critique amounted to a bit of adolescent behavior meant to shock the priggish, stuffy, dusty old traditional profession of intellectual history.  By starting his comment with an offhanded "oh, hell," and ending it with a nonchalant reference to "farting in the museum" (something, alas, I will never be able to un-read), Wickberg was attempting to demonstrate that if Livingston's "screed" is falling on deaf ears, it's not because historians are scandalized by his potty-mouthed language.  It's because he's not making a convincing argument.

But if you don't bring a knife to a gun fight, I guess you don't bring a fart to a shit-slinging contest.  Livingston's reply to Wickberg's charge of "farting in the museum" was an affectionate and admiring "fuck you."

"What the hell," I thought.  "He did NOT just say that."

It's not that I was scandalized or even surprised by Livingston's reply.  (It's not that I wasn't ever so slightly amused by it, either.)  Instead, I was disappointed. I wanted to hear the argument that Dan had invited him to make.

So I wrote Jim and told him that he blew it; he missed an opportunity to make his case to someone who represents the profession in a way that is open to critique and willing to take Livingston's ideas seriously. 

"You have to admit," I wrote, "he rolled out the red carpet for you to deliver a damning indictment of the whole discipline.  A scathing Jeremiad.  But you have too much of the Prophet Ezekiel about you today.  But whenever you're ready to write a guest post, let me know."

I am very pleased to say that Jim Livingston took me up on my offer.  He has written a thoughtful essay that is predictably provocative, but perhaps profitably so as well. 

It's not a scathing jeremiad, nor is it the cryptic musing of a prophet too easily mistaken for a madman.  In this essay, which will be published here on the blog on Thursday, Livingston revisits and to a certain extent revises his earlier critique of Paul Murphy's book.  He does so as part of an insightful meditation on the practice and purpose of doing history.  Indeed, to call this piece a "historiographic essay" doesn't quite do it justice.  Such a description gets at the genre but not the gist, the type but not the tone.  Livingston's essay is historiographical, and then some -- it is an inescapably elegiac homage to the historical profession, a profession that must not be content with writing elegies.

Senin, 30 April 2012

Welcome, Elisabeth Lasch-Quinn...and Other Changes!

We are delighted to announce the latest addition to the team here at the U.S. Intellectual History Blog: Elisabeth Lasch-Quinn, who will be joining us as our regular Sunday blogger.  Elisabeth is Professor of History at the Maxwell School of Syracuse University, and is the author of, among other works, Race Experts: How Racial Etiquette, Sensitivity Training, and New Age Therapy Hijacked the Civil Rights Revolution and Black Neighbors: Race and the Limits of Reform in the American Settlement House Movement, 1890-1945. She also blogs at Longing for the Real.

Elisabeth is an old friend of S-USIH (to the extent that scholarly societies less than a year old can have old friends).  She participated as a panel commentator at our 2009 Conference.  At the 2010 Conference, she was part of a plenary panel entitled "Intellectual History For What?"  And at last year's S-USIH Conference, she presented a brown-bag talk on the state of intellectual history. It was my honor and pleasure to be at the last two of these presentations and was struck, on both occasions, by Elisabeth's commitment to both intellectual seriousness and intellectual community, challenging us to be better scholars and better friends.  I like to think that these are values that we strive for at this blog. I know that Elisabeth will help us achieve both. 

More USIH Blog announcements after the fold...


Some perceptive readers may have noticed that a disclaimer recently showed up in our right margin:
The Society for U.S. Intellectual History is a nonprofit, nonpartisan educational organization that has applied to the Internal Revenue Service for tax-exempt status. The opinions expressed on the blog are strictly those of the individual writers and do not represent those of the Society or of the writers' employers.
As a new professional association, S-USIH is applying for 501(c)(3) non-profit status. And one of the restrictions placed on 501(c)(3)s is that they are "absolutely prohibited from directly or indirectly participating in, or intervening in, any political campaign on behalf of (or in opposition to) any candidate for elective public office."  Since this blog is affiliated with S-USIH, we need to be sure to steer clear of violating this regulation.  This disclaimer is part of that effort: it reiterates that none of the bloggers at USIH speak for the Society.  Additionally, each of our regular bloggers have made a commitment to refrain from intervening in favor or against any current candidate for elective public office in their future posts on this blog. 

Our right margin features another new gadget: once again, this blog will be participating in the For the Love of Film film preservation blogathon. This year's blogathon will take place from May 13 to 18 and will focus on Alfred Hitchcock.  Funds raised by donations during the blogathon will benefit the National Film Preservation Foundation's goal of recording a score to Alfred Hitchcock's silent The White Shadow (1923) and streaming the restored film on their website.  This year's blogathon will be co-hosted by Self-Styled Siren, Ferdy on Films, and This Island Rod.

Senin, 14 November 2011

Conference Week is Upon Us!

As most readers of this blog know, this Thursday and Friday the Fourth Annual U.S. Intellectual History Conference will be taking place at CUNY Graduate Center in New York.*

For the first time, however, this blog is not the sponsor of the conference. Instead, the conference is being run by our new parent organization, the Society for U.S. Intellectual History (S-USIH).  The Society grew out of the success of this blog and the earlier conferences.  The decision to form it was announced at the last conference.  And this year's conference is, among other things, a sort of coming-out party for S-USIH. 

That being said, for the moment at least, there's still a lot of overlap between the USIH bloggers and the S-USIH Conference Committee, Executive Committee, and leadership.  Ray Haberski and I both serve on this year's Conference Committee.  Ray is also the Secretary of S-USIH. I'm the Publications Chair.  Andrew Hartman is the President of S-USIH.  And both Tim Lacy and Lauren Kientz Anderson serve on S-USIH committees.  Many of us will also be taking part in panels at the Conference.

Although I cannot speak for my fellow bloggers, I suspect that our various Conference and S-USIH responsibilities may make things a little quiet on this blog for a few days.  But if the past is any indication, expect the Conference itself to generate a ton of grist for the USIH Blog mill in coming weeks!

I hope to see many of you in New York later this week!
________________________________________
* More information about the conference schedule can be found here.  If you're in the area, we hope you consider attending even if you are not taking part (registration costs $60, which is cheap as these things go).