Tampilkan postingan dengan label Dan Rodgers. Tampilkan semua postingan
Tampilkan postingan dengan label Dan Rodgers. Tampilkan semua postingan

Sabtu, 17 Maret 2012

Congratulations to Daniel Rodgers

On behalf of all the writers and readers of the U.S. Intellectual History blog, as well as the members and friends of the Society for U.S. Intellectual History, we wish to congratulate Daniel T. Rodgers, who was recently named as one of three winners of the 2012 Bancroft Prize. 

We knew that Age of Fracture was an Important Book.  Andrew Hartman made that call for the USIH blog on January 4, 2011.  He wrote, "A new book by Daniel Rodgers, The Age of Fracture, which I predict will be the most talked about work of intellectual history since Louis Menand’s Metaphysical Club, implies that Marx’s thesis is a pretty good explanation for our postmodern condition."

Well...


What Daniel Rodgers's book implies became a subject of repeated inquiry and rigorous debate here on the blog and in the intellectual history blogosphere generally.  Andrew launched the discussion of Age of Fracture with a response to Lisa Szefel's review of Rodgers's book (History News Network), and followed his invocation of Szefel's critique with some reflections of his own ("The Culture Wars: Notes Towards a Working Definition").  Fellow blog authors Ben Alpers ("Pulling a Thread: How Should Intellectual Historians Deal with Erroneous, Foolish, or Vicious Thought?" ), Tim Lacy ("Who's In? The Hierarchy of Intellectuals"), Ray Haberski ("What Fractured?"),  David Sehat ("Intellectual History and the Age of Fracture, Part I") and Mike O'Connor ("more on 'Age of Fracture'") picked up the discussion and carried it forward, backward, and sideways, with the enthusiastic participation of commenters known and unknown.*

Indeed, in a marvelous bit of mimesis, Daniel Rodgers and his brilliant book spread across the USIH cosmos (on this blog and well beyond it) like the very contagion of metaphors he so brilliantly, thickly and deftly described.

A highlight of the fourth annual USIH conference (the first to be held under the auspices of the newly organized S-USIH) was an entire session devoted to discussing Rodgers's Age of Fracture.  Ben Alpers chaired the roundtable; Andrew Hartman,  James Livingston, Lisa Szefel, and Mary Dudziak offered careful, critical reviews of the work.  Daniel Rodgers responded thoughtfully to these thoughtful interlocutors, and answered questions from the audience -- though, as is only fitting for such a thought-provoking book, his cryptic, coy replies may have raised more questions than they answered.

Beyond question, though, is the breathtaking brilliance of Age of Fracture.  Daniel Rodgers managed to frame the epistemic frame of an age in such a way that others are able to glimpse its contours, even as we stand within it.  That is no small feat, and this is no small book.

We are all delighted that Daniel Rodgers has been honored for this remarkable work.


------------
*I have provided links to just a few of more than a score of posts on this blog labeled with the keywords "Age of Fracture" or "Daniel Rodgers." There are many more posts where Rodgers, his book, and his ideas are the subject of discussion in the text and the comments.

Kamis, 30 Juni 2011

"Almost Always Polemical": Common Sense, Mortimer Adler, and Late Twentieth-Century Liberalism (Part I)

In April of this year I wrote a post titled "Great Books Liberalism." In that piece I cited Mortimer J. Adler's 1970 book, The Time of Our Lives: The Ethics of Common Sense, as part of my larger effort to reveal the mid-century vital center-type liberalism that formed the politics of at least one prominent great books supporter. At the time I asked readers to momentarily set aside their doubts about the currency and viability of the phrase 'common sense'---doubts I revealed that I shared. What I want to do now is fully engage those doubts, meaning in relation to philosophy, history, politics, and the great books idea. My hypothesis is that 'common sense' is one of those paradoxical, maddening, inadequate, and, sadly, indispensable tropes of any democratic culture. In other words, if you want to stir thinking and reflection into any pluralistic pot with democratic aspirations, ultimately you will likely have to reckon with either 'common sense' or a similar shorthand.

Why? Or, why do intellectual historians who write about the United States---aside from me---need to concern themselves with the fate, or movements, of 'common sense'? I'm not sure I can answer this question to everyone's satisfaction. But I can, for starters, relay something significant about the phrase from at least one other historian. Daniel Rodgers, in Age of Fracture, offers the following as a form of his book's thesis (bolds mine):

"Most striking of all [from the 1970s to the present] was the range across which the intellectual assumptions that had defined the common sense of public intellectual life since the Second World War were challenged, dismantled, and formulated anew" (p. 2).

I think Rodgers meant, in this passage, the common sensibilities of post-war intellectuals rather than 'common sense' as it is used everyday. But let's explore his usage further. Rodgers goes on to use the term in relation to public thought assumptions and movements in four other passages (bolds mine):

(a) Knowing "the pressures of society on the self was…to speak within the bounds of the prevailing common sense of the matter" (p. 5);
(b) "Certain game-theory set pieces—the free-rider problem, the prisoner's dilemma, the tragedy of the commons—became fixtures of common sense" (p. 10);
(c) "As people tried to think their way through events and experiences using the shifting stock of categories at their disposal, the terrain of common sense shifted" (p. 12); and
(d) "[Reagan] claimed no special knowledge, no expertise, no special qualities of leadership beyond the embodiment of the public's common sense" (p.33).

So Rodgers's usage is mixed (i.e. who controls the meaning and usage of 'common sense'---politicians? intellectuals? the public?). Even so, it's clear that some understanding of 'common sense' is necessary to properly read his history of social, cultural, and intellectual fracture in the late twentieth century.

I listed the passages above according to page appearance, but the last, as a segue, touches on the political problem of 'common sense' most disliked by both the left, currently, and those who mistrust populism. Most late twentieth-century appeals to 'common sense' (May I drop the quotes now? Thanks!) have been by populist leaders, like Reagan, appealing to conservatives. In true Rodgers style, I looked for a way to search presidential speeches collectively for references to common sense and couldn't find one (tried here). But I'd hazard a guess that the phrase appears more often in the public utterances of relatively "popular" two-term presidents like Bill Clinton and George W. Bush.

Despite the singular (potential) link to Clinton and Democrats, I think that the party mostly likely to appeal to common sense is the one with demonstrated anti-intellectual rhetorical tendencies---namely, Republicans since the Progressive Era. In other words, those currently on the political left will probably have visceral reactions to common sense appeals. I say this, of course, with no sense of ironic cavil; my hunch is that only left-leaning academic political philosophers would be excessively annoyed with left-leaning populist candidates who utilized appeals to common sense.

Speaking of politics and intellectuals, Ben Alpers indirectly reflected on late twentieth-century political uses of common sense when, in January 2009, he wrote here about "White House Intellectuals" (with a follow-up here). In that first post Ben cited the appearance of Leo Strauss disciple Robert Goldwin as the Ford administration's intellectual-in-residence. Here's the provocative money quote from Goldwin on common sense (bolds mine):

"There is something fishy about the word 'intellectual. …I think of 'intellectuals' as people who have a real distaste, sometimes even contempt, for the common sense approach, which is fundamentally the political approach."

The quote literally drips with what Leon Kass (another Straussian) called the "wisdom of repugnance." That aside, we see in Goldman a Republican administration purposely contrasting the "fishy" intellectual approach with the common sense way solving problems. Goldwin pretty clearly implies that intellectuals prefer top-down, pseudo-fascist bureaucratic means of problem solving, versus populist politicians who appeal to "the people" and seek to understand bottom-up majority opinion, if not the popular consensus. In sum, no Democrat would resort to common sense populism when an effete, eggheaded bureaucrat could get you to the desired end.

Rodgers history, my gloss, and Ben's example, however, obscure the longer political and intellectual history of appeals to common sense. That lacuna is covered, somewhat, by a brand new book I indirectly referenced in my April post: Sophia Rosenfeld's Common Sense: A Political History (Harvard Press, May 2011). Professor Rosenfeld is an historian of early modern Europe and the Atlantic world employed by the University of Virginia. Although I have put out an inter-library loan call for her book, my only access to it at this point is by way of (a) the publisher's blurb and (b) a short write-up by Josh Rothman at the Boston Globe's "Brainiac" blog.

Assuming it is reasonably reflective of the product at hand, the press blurb tells us the following:

Common sense has always been a cornerstone of American politics. In 1776, Tom Paine’s vital pamphlet with that title sparked the American Revolution. And today, common sense—the wisdom of ordinary people, knowledge so self-evident that it is beyond debate—remains a powerful political ideal, utilized alike by George W. Bush’s aw-shucks articulations and Barack Obama’s down-to-earth reasonableness. But far from self-evident is where our faith in common sense comes from and how its populist logic has shaped modern democracy.

I'm struck by these key phrases and words: "always…a cornerstone," "wisdom of ordinary people," "self-evident," "beyond debate," and "faith." Here's the second paragraph from the blurb:

The story begins in the aftermath of England’s Glorious Revolution, when common sense first became a political ideal worth struggling over. Sophia Rosenfeld’s accessible and insightful account then wends its way across two continents and multiple centuries, revealing the remarkable individuals who appropriated the old, seemingly universal idea of common sense and the new strategic uses they made of it. Paine may have boasted that common sense is always on the side of the people and opposed to the rule of kings, but Rosenfeld demonstrates that common sense has been used to foster demagoguery and exclusivity as well as popular sovereignty. She provides a new account of the transatlantic Enlightenment and the Age of Revolutions, and offers a fresh reading on what the eighteenth century bequeathed to the political ferment of our own time. Far from commonsensical, the history of common sense turns out to be rife with paradox and surprise.

More key ideas and points: "a political ideal," used to "foster demagoguery…exclusivity…[and] popular sovereignty."

Here's what Rothman had to say about Rosenfeld's book (bolds mine---aside: notice the similarities and differences with the blurb):

-------------------------------------------------------------
Common sense has a special place in modern politics. Politicians constantly appeal to it in their arguments, and they do so because democracy itself is founded on a faith in common sense. In 1776, for instance, Thomas Paine wrote, in his pamphlet Common Sense, that "simple facts, plain arguments, and common sense" would suffice to place the rights of the people above the rights of the king. The king, and many others, disagreed; and yet today common sense seems, so to speak, self-evident.

The truth is, as usual, more complicated. …Common sense was invented by scientists, philosophers, and politicians. It only seems self-evident now because the idea of common sense presents itself as common-sensical, as though everyone, were he not disabused of the notion by experts, would know that he possessed it. Common sense is…a "slippery" idea -- the kind of idea that covers its own tracks.

Rosenfeld's account of common sense centers on the eighteenth century, when common sense and the scientific method both got their starts. Both ways of thinking about thinking [i.e. epistemology], she writes, began with "a Protestant emphasis on direct, experiential knowledge, simplicity, and the value of 'ordinary life.'" Enlightenment thinkers, who championed reason over tradition and superstition, often cited something not unlike common sense as the quality that authorized them to set aside received ideas and come to their own conclusions. But that alliance was not to last. Science became increasingly specialized, and thinking, especially in print, more rigorous, complicated, and systematized.

Rosenfeld ties her story to a number of large historical developments throughout the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries. Living in thriving, cosmopolitan cities gave ordinary people the sense that their (actually very local) intuitions might be universally true. Well-educated media types -- think Thomas Paine -- began presenting themselves as representatives of "the people," in an effort to find a middle position in an economically stratified society. And people in authority, overwhelmed by an explosion of books and pamphlets, began using the idea of "common sense" to disqualify ideas they didn't like as absurd or inappropriate. What emerges from this history is that, as Rosenfeld puts it, "common sense is almost never fully consensual;" instead, ideas about what's common-sensical are "almost always polemical."

-------------------------------------------------------------

What are we to take away from Rosenfeld's history---assuming these passages above accurately reflect the contents of her book?

The political usage of common sense over time is clearly "rife with paradox" and inconsistencies. This is probably not surprising to most of us. Past and present politicians have a penchant for using words, terms, and phrases for personal gain---irrespective of truth, philosophy, and consistency. Nevertheless, Rothman reports Rosenfeld to argue that "democracy itself is founded on a faith in common sense." This is probably disheartening to a significant number of intellectuals, but I think she's right. I can't decide, however, if this says more about the fragility of democracy or the tentative nature of knowledge. In either case, today's usage of common sense is indeed "almost always political"---if mostly anchored in right-wing politics.

But, if we can set aside the uses and abuses of common sense by politicians, Rosenfeld also tells us that we should take seriously the intellectual foundations of common sense. ...

Let me stop here, however, since this post is getting overly long. Next week I'll try to connect those serious intellectual foundations with Mortimer Adler, the great books, and late twentieth-century liberalism. Stay tuned! - TL

"Almost Always Polemical": Common Sense, Mortimer Adler, and Late Twentieth-Century Liberalism (Part I)

In April of this year I wrote a post titled "Great Books Liberalism." In that piece I cited Mortimer J. Adler's 1970 book, The Time of Our Lives: The Ethics of Common Sense, as part of my larger effort to reveal the mid-century vital center-type liberalism that formed the politics of at least one prominent great books supporter. At the time I asked readers to momentarily set aside their doubts about the currency and viability of the phrase 'common sense'---doubts I revealed that I shared. What I want to do now is fully engage those doubts, meaning in relation to philosophy, history, politics, and the great books idea. My hypothesis is that 'common sense' is one of those paradoxical, maddening, inadequate, and, sadly, indispensable tropes of any democratic culture. In other words, if you want to stir thinking and reflection into any pluralistic pot with democratic aspirations, ultimately you will likely have to reckon with either 'common sense' or a similar shorthand.

Why? Or, why do intellectual historians who write about the United States---aside from me---need to concern themselves with the fate, or movements, of 'common sense'? I'm not sure I can answer this question to everyone's satisfaction. But I can, for starters, relay something significant about the phrase from at least one other historian. Daniel Rodgers, in Age of Fracture, offers the following as a form of his book's thesis (bolds mine):

"Most striking of all [from the 1970s to the present] was the range across which the intellectual assumptions that had defined the common sense of public intellectual life since the Second World War were challenged, dismantled, and formulated anew" (p. 2).

I think Rodgers meant, in this passage, the common sensibilities of post-war intellectuals rather than 'common sense' as it is used everyday. But let's explore his usage further. Rodgers goes on to use the term in relation to public thought assumptions and movements in four other passages (bolds mine):

(a) Knowing "the pressures of society on the self was…to speak within the bounds of the prevailing common sense of the matter" (p. 5);
(b) "Certain game-theory set pieces—the free-rider problem, the prisoner's dilemma, the tragedy of the commons—became fixtures of common sense" (p. 10);
(c) "As people tried to think their way through events and experiences using the shifting stock of categories at their disposal, the terrain of common sense shifted" (p. 12); and
(d) "[Reagan] claimed no special knowledge, no expertise, no special qualities of leadership beyond the embodiment of the public's common sense" (p.33).

So Rodgers's usage is mixed (i.e. who controls the meaning and usage of 'common sense'---politicians? intellectuals? the public?). Even so, it's clear that some understanding of 'common sense' is necessary to properly read his history of social, cultural, and intellectual fracture in the late twentieth century.

I listed the passages above according to page appearance, but the last, as a segue, touches on the political problem of 'common sense' most disliked by both the left, currently, and those who mistrust populism. Most late twentieth-century appeals to 'common sense' (May I drop the quotes now? Thanks!) have been by populist leaders, like Reagan, appealing to conservatives. In true Rodgers style, I looked for a way to search presidential speeches collectively for references to common sense and couldn't find one (tried here). But I'd hazard a guess that the phrase appears more often in the public utterances of relatively "popular" two-term presidents like Bill Clinton and George W. Bush.

Despite the singular (potential) link to Clinton and Democrats, I think that the party mostly likely to appeal to common sense is the one with demonstrated anti-intellectual rhetorical tendencies---namely, Republicans since the Progressive Era. In other words, those currently on the political left will probably have visceral reactions to common sense appeals. I say this, of course, with no sense of ironic cavil; my hunch is that only left-leaning academic political philosophers would be excessively annoyed with left-leaning populist candidates who utilized appeals to common sense.

Speaking of politics and intellectuals, Ben Alpers indirectly reflected on late twentieth-century political uses of common sense when, in January 2009, he wrote here about "White House Intellectuals" (with a follow-up here). In that first post Ben cited the appearance of Leo Strauss disciple Robert Goldwin as the Ford administration's intellectual-in-residence. Here's the provocative money quote from Goldwin on common sense (bolds mine):

"There is something fishy about the word 'intellectual. …I think of 'intellectuals' as people who have a real distaste, sometimes even contempt, for the common sense approach, which is fundamentally the political approach."

The quote literally drips with what Leon Kass (another Straussian) called the "wisdom of repugnance." That aside, we see in Goldman a Republican administration purposely contrasting the "fishy" intellectual approach with the common sense way solving problems. Goldwin pretty clearly implies that intellectuals prefer top-down, pseudo-fascist bureaucratic means of problem solving, versus populist politicians who appeal to "the people" and seek to understand bottom-up majority opinion, if not the popular consensus. In sum, no Democrat would resort to common sense populism when an effete, eggheaded bureaucrat could get you to the desired end.

Rodgers history, my gloss, and Ben's example, however, obscure the longer political and intellectual history of appeals to common sense. That lacuna is covered, somewhat, by a brand new book I indirectly referenced in my April post: Sophia Rosenfeld's Common Sense: A Political History (Harvard Press, May 2011). Professor Rosenfeld is an historian of early modern Europe and the Atlantic world employed by the University of Virginia. Although I have put out an inter-library loan call for her book, my only access to it at this point is by way of (a) the publisher's blurb and (b) a short write-up by Josh Rothman at the Boston Globe's "Brainiac" blog.

Assuming it is reasonably reflective of the product at hand, the press blurb tells us the following:

Common sense has always been a cornerstone of American politics. In 1776, Tom Paine’s vital pamphlet with that title sparked the American Revolution. And today, common sense—the wisdom of ordinary people, knowledge so self-evident that it is beyond debate—remains a powerful political ideal, utilized alike by George W. Bush’s aw-shucks articulations and Barack Obama’s down-to-earth reasonableness. But far from self-evident is where our faith in common sense comes from and how its populist logic has shaped modern democracy.

I'm struck by these key phrases and words: "always…a cornerstone," "wisdom of ordinary people," "self-evident," "beyond debate," and "faith." Here's the second paragraph from the blurb:

The story begins in the aftermath of England’s Glorious Revolution, when common sense first became a political ideal worth struggling over. Sophia Rosenfeld’s accessible and insightful account then wends its way across two continents and multiple centuries, revealing the remarkable individuals who appropriated the old, seemingly universal idea of common sense and the new strategic uses they made of it. Paine may have boasted that common sense is always on the side of the people and opposed to the rule of kings, but Rosenfeld demonstrates that common sense has been used to foster demagoguery and exclusivity as well as popular sovereignty. She provides a new account of the transatlantic Enlightenment and the Age of Revolutions, and offers a fresh reading on what the eighteenth century bequeathed to the political ferment of our own time. Far from commonsensical, the history of common sense turns out to be rife with paradox and surprise.

More key ideas and points: "a political ideal," used to "foster demagoguery…exclusivity…[and] popular sovereignty."

Here's what Rothman had to say about Rosenfeld's book (bolds mine---aside: notice the similarities and differences with the blurb):

-------------------------------------------------------------
Common sense has a special place in modern politics. Politicians constantly appeal to it in their arguments, and they do so because democracy itself is founded on a faith in common sense. In 1776, for instance, Thomas Paine wrote, in his pamphlet Common Sense, that "simple facts, plain arguments, and common sense" would suffice to place the rights of the people above the rights of the king. The king, and many others, disagreed; and yet today common sense seems, so to speak, self-evident.

The truth is, as usual, more complicated. …Common sense was invented by scientists, philosophers, and politicians. It only seems self-evident now because the idea of common sense presents itself as common-sensical, as though everyone, were he not disabused of the notion by experts, would know that he possessed it. Common sense is…a "slippery" idea -- the kind of idea that covers its own tracks.

Rosenfeld's account of common sense centers on the eighteenth century, when common sense and the scientific method both got their starts. Both ways of thinking about thinking [i.e. epistemology], she writes, began with "a Protestant emphasis on direct, experiential knowledge, simplicity, and the value of 'ordinary life.'" Enlightenment thinkers, who championed reason over tradition and superstition, often cited something not unlike common sense as the quality that authorized them to set aside received ideas and come to their own conclusions. But that alliance was not to last. Science became increasingly specialized, and thinking, especially in print, more rigorous, complicated, and systematized.

Rosenfeld ties her story to a number of large historical developments throughout the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries. Living in thriving, cosmopolitan cities gave ordinary people the sense that their (actually very local) intuitions might be universally true. Well-educated media types -- think Thomas Paine -- began presenting themselves as representatives of "the people," in an effort to find a middle position in an economically stratified society. And people in authority, overwhelmed by an explosion of books and pamphlets, began using the idea of "common sense" to disqualify ideas they didn't like as absurd or inappropriate. What emerges from this history is that, as Rosenfeld puts it, "common sense is almost never fully consensual;" instead, ideas about what's common-sensical are "almost always polemical."

-------------------------------------------------------------

What are we to take away from Rosenfeld's history---assuming these passages above accurately reflect the contents of her book?

The political usage of common sense over time is clearly "rife with paradox" and inconsistencies. This is probably not surprising to most of us. Past and present politicians have a penchant for using words, terms, and phrases for personal gain---irrespective of truth, philosophy, and consistency. Nevertheless, Rothman reports Rosenfeld to argue that "democracy itself is founded on a faith in common sense." This is probably disheartening to a significant number of intellectuals, but I think she's right. I can't decide, however, if this says more about the fragility of democracy or the tentative nature of knowledge. In either case, today's usage of common sense is indeed "almost always political"---if mostly anchored in right-wing politics.

But, if we can set aside the uses and abuses of common sense by politicians, Rosenfeld also tells us that we should take seriously the intellectual foundations of common sense. ...

Let me stop here, however, since this post is getting overly long. Next week I'll try to connect those serious intellectual foundations with Mortimer Adler, the great books, and late twentieth-century liberalism. Stay tuned! - TL

Senin, 14 Maret 2011

Judging A Book By Its Cover

I just returned today from a long weekend celebrating my mother's 75th birthday, so I'm not going to make as substantive an addition to the fascinating Age of Fracture-inspired conversations that have been taking place on this blog as I would have liked (that'll have to wait until next week).

But I happened to bring Rodgers's book along with me on my trip and spent most of my plane ride today reading it. And though I have a lot of thoughts about it to share, I'm going to limit my post today to a minor point that hasn't--so far as I know--been mentioned here or in other discussions about the book: its cover.



The cover is in most ways terrific. It's visually striking. And it seems to illustrate the book's title and theme.  It's a fractured image...in red, white, (black), and blue.  I also love the way the title and author's name reflect its colors.

But there's one problem with this cover that perhaps shouldn't bug me, but does:  the image is a detail of a Study for a Drawing by Stuart Davis, a painter most associated with the 1940s and 1950s, who passed away in 1964; this particular work was made in 1955.  Especially since no dates appear on the cover of the book, it seems to me to be an odd choice for the cover of a book about the 1970s, 1980s, and 1990s.  Davis is a familiar enough artist with a distinctive enough style that, at least to me, this cover says 1940s not 1970s (and beyond). And there are surely works of art from the period covered by the book that illustrate fracture equally well.


All of this led me to think about what makes for a good cover of an academic history book.  We should all be so lucky as to have anything as well designed as Age of Fracture's cover grace our own books.  Incidentally, Dan Rodgers has had two visually effective covers in a row. Atlantic Crossings also has a wonderfully powerful cover.  In this case, the image is from the period on which the book focuses, although it doesn't entirely illustrate what the book is about; it's more a riff on the book's excellent title.

Of course, getting an image that actually does in some sense illustrate the book's theme can be tricky, especially in intellectual history.  Still it's occasionally possible to do so.

One of my classmates in graduate school used to joke that if you closely studied the cover of Elaine Tyler May's Homeward Bound,  you didn't have to read the book.  In saying this, he wasn't insulting May; in fact, he liked the book a lot. He just thought that its cover perfectly illustrated May's argument.

Since USIH seems to be in a list-making mood these days, what do you think are the great book covers in American intellectual history...and what makes them so good?

Judging A Book By Its Cover

I just returned today from a long weekend celebrating my mother's 75th birthday, so I'm not going to make as substantive an addition to the fascinating Age of Fracture-inspired conversations that have been taking place on this blog as I would have liked (that'll have to wait until next week).

But I happened to bring Rodgers's book along with me on my trip and spent most of my plane ride today reading it. And though I have a lot of thoughts about it to share, I'm going to limit my post today to a minor point that hasn't--so far as I know--been mentioned here or in other discussions about the book: its cover.



The cover is in most ways terrific. It's visually striking. And it seems to illustrate the book's title and theme.  It's a fractured image...in red, white, (black), and blue.  I also love the way the title and author's name reflect its colors.

But there's one problem with this cover that perhaps shouldn't bug me, but does:  the image is a detail of a Study for a Drawing by Stuart Davis, a painter most associated with the 1940s and 1950s, who passed away in 1964; this particular work was made in 1955.  Especially since no dates appear on the cover of the book, it seems to me to be an odd choice for the cover of a book about the 1970s, 1980s, and 1990s.  Davis is a familiar enough artist with a distinctive enough style that, at least to me, this cover says 1940s not 1970s (and beyond). And there are surely works of art from the period covered by the book that illustrate fracture equally well.


All of this led me to think about what makes for a good cover of an academic history book.  We should all be so lucky as to have anything as well designed as Age of Fracture's cover grace our own books.  Incidentally, Dan Rodgers has had two visually effective covers in a row. Atlantic Crossings also has a wonderfully powerful cover.  In this case, the image is from the period on which the book focuses, although it doesn't entirely illustrate what the book is about; it's more a riff on the book's excellent title.

Of course, getting an image that actually does in some sense illustrate the book's theme can be tricky, especially in intellectual history.  Still it's occasionally possible to do so.

One of my classmates in graduate school used to joke that if you closely studied the cover of Elaine Tyler May's Homeward Bound,  you didn't have to read the book.  In saying this, he wasn't insulting May; in fact, he liked the book a lot. He just thought that its cover perfectly illustrated May's argument.

Since USIH seems to be in a list-making mood these days, what do you think are the great book covers in American intellectual history...and what makes them so good?